DCG - Plugins Fun Discussion

DartanbeckDartanbeck Posts: 21,326
edited November 2014 in Carrara Discussion

A while back, a good Carrara friend of mine bought for me three fine products from DCG (Digital Carvers Guild), maker of fine plugins for enhancing Carrara and LightWave, and I've found scarce little time to actually experiment with them - always meaning to get back and try them out. Well, you know how that may have turned out: Good intentions led to just continuing on in my usual, comfort zone of creating and editing shaders in Carrara's wonderful Texture room.

Roygee has a thread going about Bryce Terrains in Carrara and DAZ_Spooky came in saying that Ground Control by DCG allows for direct importing of certain elevation maps into Carrara terrains. I mentioned in there that I really long to buy Terrain Tools, which helps make shaders that detect where objects intersect, so we can make different effects happen at those intersections, like shoreline froth, shallow transparency, etc., and suddenly realized that I already own a bunch of cool features that I've not yet gotten into! Yikes! Do I even deserve Terrain Tools? Would I just let it sit? Time to plug some of these tools into my shaders and check them out!

===============================================================================================

For starters, I started looking through some of the tutorials at the DCG site. Upon checking out the new features that ShaderOps 2's Light Mangler adds to SSS (Subsurface Scattering), I had to try this out! SSS has been a hot topic in the past, why not have a look, eh?

So for my first run, I decided to use one of Mec4D's Homo Erectus, and decided upon the M4 one, for more free real estate of the figure before breaking TOS! LOL
Cat (Mec4D) was kind enough to include a whole slew of maps for us to moonkey around with in the Homo Erectus products, so that's how I decided to begin there. You see, Carrara's SSS channel only allows for a single color chip, and a few controls. Shader Ops 2's Light Mangler changes all of that. In addition to its own new functions, it also adds all other Carrara shader functions to the list of options for SSS, including gradients, values, noises, etc., and I wanted to try using the Texture Maps that Cat made, since she included some for use in the SSS channel.

After a bit of playing around with it, here's my first showing, which is my third try. It's still not right, but I wanted to show my progress before I get too far with this.

Anyone else have some DCG experiences to share?

DCG-LightMang-SSS-HomoErectusM4A.jpg
1680 x 945 - 817K
Post edited by Dartanbeck on

Comments

  • DartanbeckDartanbeck Posts: 21,326
    edited December 1969

    To gain these extra functions in this case, I set the Top Shader to "ShaderOps 2 - Light Mangler"
    The original shader that I had set up was kept as the top line of the tree, called: "Shader"
    A whole pile of new channels now appear, including the new Subsurface Scattering Channel, which allows for any of Carrara's shader functions to be used within it, as well as some new Shader Ops 2 functions as well.
    At this point, I have yet to try any of these other new channels - but I will.

    To get the above image, I nested together ShaderOps2 - Calculate SSS multiplied by a Color Gradient controlled by Cat's SSS texture map.
    I repeated this process through all of the fleshy material zones.

    DCG-LightMang-TRoomA.jpg
    1429 x 718 - 421K
  • DartanbeckDartanbeck Posts: 21,326
    edited December 1969

    Same scene without Light Mangler on the fleshy shaders

    DCG-HomoErectusM4A-nodcgss.jpg
    1680 x 945 - 802K
  • DartanbeckDartanbeck Posts: 21,326
    edited December 1969

    Now to look deeper into this particular effect and see how I can fix it. So far I was just messing around. I'd like to find out how different functions can help to make the SSS really work the way I'd like to see SSS work. As well, I'd like to investigate the rest of these Enhance C, Shader Ops, and Shader Ops 2 features!

  • evilproducerevilproducer Posts: 9,050
    edited December 1969

    For SSS to look the best, it really needs a strong light source. Backlighting is good for showing off the ears and other thin areas. A good side light would show off the spread of light through the skin. A good example would be getting a nice rosy look to the cheeks.

    So many times I see SSS make the character look like they're made out of wax. The worse examples I have seen have actually been from unbiased renderers. It is not that the renderers are the issue, but the user probably doesn't know when to dial the settings back. Thankfully, dustrider and joeping are gifted and talented and know what they're doing so I haven't noticed the issue with their renders. I actually began noticing it when Reality came out for Studio and folks were posting their Reality renders.

  • DartanbeckDartanbeck Posts: 21,326
    edited December 1969

    Just messing around on a plane, I found this cool "Pipes" function in Enhance C

    DCG-EC-Pipes1a.jpg
    910 x 518 - 114K
  • DartanbeckDartanbeck Posts: 21,326
    edited December 1969

    For SSS to look the best, it really needs a strong light source. Backlighting is good for showing off the ears and other thin areas. A good side light would show off the spread of light through the skin. A good example would be getting a nice rosy look to the cheeks.

    So many times I see SSS make the character look like they're made out of wax. The worse examples I have seen have actually been from unbiased renderers. It is not that the renderers are the issue, but the user probably doesn't know when to dial the settings back. Thankfully, dustrider and joeping are gifted and talented and know what they're doing so I haven't noticed the issue with their renders. I actually began noticing it when Reality came out for Studio and folks were posting their Reality renders.

    Right. This one does have a strong back light - perhaps too strong... but then plenty of other light surrounding him too, using that BG and GI.
    You're right, I'll do some better tests next week with a darker scene and lights that intend to help illustrate what the SSS is doing. It was easy for me to see the difference, being in the driver's seat! LOL
  • DartanbeckDartanbeck Posts: 21,326
    edited December 1969

    I put the above "pipes" image into Howler 9.5's 3D Designer, exported an obj file of it, and duplicated it in Carrara with a modified "lead" shader

    Howler3D-PipesOBver.jpg
    1280 x 720 - 594K
  • HeadwaxHeadwax Posts: 9,964

    and then what happened?

    can you show us some more eggsamples?

    • That PD Howler 3D designer looks like a cool tool in itself, and I know how you love extolling the virtues of Dogwaffle so expect we shall get a bit more information about it.
    • maybe a small missive cheeky
  • PhilWPhilW Posts: 5,144
    edited September 2015

    Couldn't you just apply that map to the displacement channel directly in Carrara and get pretty much the same result? Actually I just tried that and the result wasn't great, but I tried it by importing the map on a terrain and that looks pretty good - here replicated in a 10x10 autogrid.

    Pipes.jpg
    640 x 480 - 53K
    Post edited by PhilW on
  • HeadwaxHeadwax Posts: 9,964

    hya Dart, I need some sss happening, how about a bit more enlightenment please ?:)

  • Now to look deeper into this particular effect and see how I can fix it. So far I was just messing around. I'd like to find out how different functions can help to make the SSS really work the way I'd like to see SSS work. As well, I'd like to investigate the rest of these Enhance C, Shader Ops, and Shader Ops 2 features!

    Why not play with Emily ?

    http://gl.ict.usc.edu/Research/DigitalEmily2/

    She is very simple model with HiRes maps ...

    Here are few renders of her in Blender Cycles (unbiased):

    http://blenderartists.org/forum/showthread.php?379147-Skin-in-Cycles-Emily-2-1

     

    Good luck smiley

  • DiomedeDiomede Posts: 15,125

    Bookmarked.  Thanks.

     

    Now to look deeper into this particular effect and see how I can fix it. So far I was just messing around. I'd like to find out how different functions can help to make the SSS really work the way I'd like to see SSS work. As well, I'd like to investigate the rest of these Enhance C, Shader Ops, and Shader Ops 2 features!

    Why not play with Emily ?

    http://gl.ict.usc.edu/Research/DigitalEmily2/

    She is very simple model with HiRes maps ...

    Here are few renders of her in Blender Cycles (unbiased):

    http://blenderartists.org/forum/showthread.php?379147-Skin-in-Cycles-Emily-2-1

     

    Good luck smiley

     

  • Well, textures are in EXR format, that can pose problems for some people, however, they can be converted into more suitable image formats with Photoshop or whatever  smiley

  • magaremotomagaremoto Posts: 1,226

    I post my test to know if anyone had luck with eyes maps: this is what I get using obj, I'm gonna try the abc format

    no sss here only a bit of translucency, slightly touched up in post, a 15 min render

    15.jpg
    2083 x 2500 - 331K
  • magaremotomagaremoto Posts: 1,226

    last OT, I promise

    another close up with a more grazing lighting

    16.jpg
    5000 x 6000 - 2M
  • PhilWPhilW Posts: 5,144

    If trying to do ultra-realistic humans, I have to say that I never thought that Carrara's native SSS gave that good results.  SSS in Octane was a revalation how good it works.

  • HeadwaxHeadwax Posts: 9,964

    last OT, I promise

    another close up with a more grazing lighting

    looks great magaremoto!

     

  • magaremotomagaremoto Posts: 1,226

    thank you head wax, in spite of strange artifacts of the provided maps the shader editor works great in carrara and the whole lighting pack available within did all the rest

    about sss I think there is a bad understanding of what it can do in carrara: it can turn the soft shadows on arms or neck, for example, into pale red to avoid a doll-like skin effect, but hardly can fire up ears when lit from behind; you can get it when you have a good transparency map (or depth map as well) and play around with translucency, like I did for this ten24 model with likely results

    2016-04-24_170236.jpg
    1920 x 1050 - 268K
    2016-04-24_170254.jpg
    1920 x 1050 - 271K
  • about sss I think there is a bad understanding of what it can do in carrara: it can turn the soft shadows on arms or neck, for example, into pale red to avoid a doll-like skin effect, but hardly can fire up ears when lit from behind

    Well, I hardly ever use it because it's slow and outdated (the only thing slower are blurred reflections, that has to be the slowest piece of code ever written).

    SSS (as of now) has been in Carrara for a while, it was originally intended for a simple SSS effect (there is no even depth and anisotropy control) and it was never updated ...

    Real skin shader, on the other hand is, in general, way too complex to be simulated with Carrara's SSS, for some reason plugin developers are not interested, simply plugging texture maps into existing SSS will not do it for me, I need more smiley

  • magaremotomagaremoto Posts: 1,226

    I agree, FifthElement

    moreover IMO sss in carrara is more a milkiness or opalescence effect, that are 2 different ways to refract light, good for materials like jade, wax, glue, latex, some minerals etc. but not for skin

    the following are the results of a quick test with a transparency map set to 5% and 20% with and without sss

     

    no sss trans5.jpg
    3000 x 2298 - 608K
    sss trans5.jpg
    3000 x 2298 - 603K
    no sss trans20.jpg
    1000 x 766 - 84K
  • magaremotomagaremoto Posts: 1,226

    ..and this the "latex" effect we get with pure sss and no transparency (or depth) map

    sss only.jpg
    1000 x 766 - 84K
  • magaremotomagaremoto Posts: 1,226
    edited April 2016

    this is the final result combining sss and transparency, slightly touched up in post; strange artefatcs due to use of caustics

     

    EDIT: tweaked the caustics to correct the weird reflections on the model, touched up in post

    Doc2.jpg
    3600 x 2757 - 942K
    Post edited by magaremoto on
Sign In or Register to comment.