Loading...
> >

Physics with linkages

KoliverKoliver Posts: 3
edited December 1969 in Carrara Discussion

I'd like to use Carrara 8.5 Pro physics to simulate kinetic sculptures before I build them. However, I can't seem to get even the simplest linkage to simulate correctly. Please take a look at the very simplified linkage photos attached and tell me what I'm doing wrong. It consists of two linkages, one grounded but free to rotate and the other attached to the first. I've moved the hot points to where the pivots should be, and applied a shaft constraint, but as soon as I hit the Physics button, the linkages go every which way, not even close to what would happen in real life.
I'm sure I'm doing something wrong but I sure can't figure out what.
Any help would be appreciated. Thanks

Linkage3.jpg
1440 x 900 - 271K
Linkage2.jpg
1440 x 900 - 265K
Linkage1.jpg
1440 x 900 - 325K

Comments

  • Philemo_CarraraPhilemo_Carrara Posts: 1,175
    edited January 2015

    Do the two links intersect before simulation ? (it's difficult to see in the snapshot).
    Could you post a snapshot of the motion tab of the second link ? (the shaft constraint should be on the second one, not the first).

    Post edited by Philemo_Carrara on
  • DUDUDUDU Posts: 1,945
    edited December 1969

    It is not so simple, with the bullet engine, if two objects are inter-penetrated, it's the explosion at the first simulated image !
    This Cripeman's tuto could be interresting : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AQIOeac29Dk&list=PL6E52B9D41A109646

  • Design AcrobatDesign Acrobat Posts: 459
    edited January 2015

    One can use soft body attach at pivot points (must have at least one vertex there to make it pivot). Unless you are doing soft body, no need to convert it to soft body, just use the soft body attachment and identify the tree to which you want it attached and mark the vertices.

    Havent done a lot of experimentation with this, but on the whim, it does work albeit there are some bumping that occurs when the point force forces a collision.


    Motion tab>Physics (100%) on the item you want to be affected by the force(s)

    Modifiers>physics>soft body attach to configure your kinetic actor.

    EDIT: Can also make invisible primitives to control how an object reacts to forces (walls to keep an object from escaping the viewing area, etc.)

    Post edited by Design Acrobat on
  • KoliverKoliver Posts: 3
    edited December 1969

    Thanks for your inputs. I've attached photos of the side view at the start of the simulation. As you can see, I've put a fairly large gap between the two links so they don't "explode". I've also attached a photo of the motion tab of the second link, which is the same as the first link. I also have the second link a child of the first link. There are no forces acting on either link other than default gravity.
    Philemo, I don't follow your comment that the shaft restraint should be on the second link, not the first. I assume you mean the the first link should have no restraint. I tried that and they both just free fall out of the screen. Perhaps you could clarify.

    Linkage5.jpg
    1440 x 900 - 265K
    Linkage4.jpg
    1440 x 900 - 334K
  • WendyLuvsCatzWendyLuvsCatz Posts: 38,192
    edited January 2015

    you need a pin in the holes I reckon
    this is just 3 vertex objects only pin and bottom one physics top two keyframe

    links.gif
    500 x 483 - 502K
    Post edited by WendyLuvsCatz on
  • WendyLuvsCatzWendyLuvsCatz Posts: 38,192
    edited December 1969

    damn I am having fun now
    only top one keyframe rest physics

    links.gif
    500 x 483 - 459K
  • KoliverKoliver Posts: 3
    edited December 1969

    Wendy, that's what I'm talking about!!
    They won't let you post .car files here, but is there any way I can get your file so I can see what genius you applied to get this to work? If that's not possible, could you post a few photos showing your settings?
    BTW, would it still work if you only had one link in the middle instead of two?
    I am totally impressed!

  • JoeMamma2000JoeMamma2000 Posts: 2,615
    edited December 1969

    There are a few ways to do linkages, depending on what you want. Physics is okay if you want stuff to act under gravity, but if you want machine-type linkages there's other methods (see attached):

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aWyh8sxkBL4

  • WendyLuvsCatzWendyLuvsCatz Posts: 38,192
    edited December 1969

    OK
    https://app.box.com/s/9sfrwwc367qsmi6pckankjxywo5qxn8y
    one pin it falls out like in real world, just think of objects and gravity
    I am playing still too LOL added cloth

    fun0025.gif
    300 x 290 - 7M
  • DUDUDUDU Posts: 1,945
    edited December 1969

    Your creativity will always astonish me, Wendy!

  • Design AcrobatDesign Acrobat Posts: 459
    edited December 1969

    wendy♥catz said:
    OK
    https://app.box.com/s/9sfrwwc367qsmi6pckankjxywo5qxn8y
    one pin it falls out like in real world, just think of objects and gravity
    I am playing still too LOL added cloth

    Most excellent Wendy!

    Had random thoughts of a robot with a fly swatter running through my mind after seeing your flying link with cloth. :)

  • evilproducerevilproducer Posts: 9,050
    edited December 1969

    Koliver said:
    Wendy, that's what I'm talking about!!
    They won't let you post .car files here, but is there any way I can get your file so I can see what genius you applied to get this to work? If that's not possible, could you post a few photos showing your settings?
    BTW, would it still work if you only had one link in the middle instead of two?
    I am totally impressed!

    The material properties and simulation accuracy will also play a big role in a physics simulation.

    AoA built a catapult that worked using Carrara's old rigid body physics and it worked, so it is possible.

  • JoeMamma2000JoeMamma2000 Posts: 2,615
    edited January 2015

    If you decide to go with physics, I wrote a short tutorial a while back that explains some of the Bullet settings you'll need to make sure stuff doesn't fly off into outer space. Settings like Bounce, Friction, and collision distance become critical in rigid physics like this.

    http://www.daz3d.com/forums/discussion/23632/

    Post edited by JoeMamma2000 on
  • JonstarkJonstark Posts: 2,738
    edited December 1969

    Somehow missed that tutorial the first time around, great stuff. Thanks Joe!

  • KoliverKoliver Posts: 3
    edited December 1969

    Thanks Wendy, just analyzing your file answered a lot of questions I had. I think I can actually make my kinetic sculpture model work now.
    Thanks also to everyone else who responded. I still think Carrara has a lot of potential and I hope the developers don't abandon it like an old pair of shoes.

Sign In or Register to comment.