Carrara Challenge #47: Structured/Unstructured - Voting Closed - Thank you everyone!

2

Comments

  • DesertDudeDesertDude Posts: 1,238
    Selinita said:

    I though I'd read to choose 5, but it seems that's just been changed to read 4, so I'm dropping choice 2 from my list - sorry Stezza!

    Sorry for the confusion, I thought I caught my error in time. There are 4 places the community votes for and then our PA Sponsor, Vyusur, will choose one image for a prize donated by her.

    Again, sorry for the error.

  • namtar3dnamtar3d Posts: 246
    edited July 2019

    1.-Entry #: 25

    Title: Destructive morphs

    Artist: Vyusur

    I like everything about this render: The concept, the colors, the filter. 

    2.-Entry #:
     2
    Title: Somedays Are Like this
    Artist: headwax-carrara

    This one is so artistic! Very nice indeed!


    3.-Entry #9
    Title: Building Dominoes
    Artist: Stezza
    Clean and funny render. 

    4.- Entry #: 6

    Title:
    When Structures are becoming unstructured.

    Artist:
    Varsel

    I love the concept! 

    Post edited by namtar3d on
  • DesertDudeDesertDude Posts: 1,238

    As usual it was very difficult to choose - these were all great entries.

    Entry #: 2
    Title: Somedays Are Like this
    Artist: headwax-carrara
    I like the wild patterns that make up the walls, the framed pictures of patterns, and the way the room seemingly falls away into darkness. What a wonderful strange place to visit.

    Entry #: 14
    Title: What a Butte Cafe !
    Artist: Bunyip02
    I'm drawn to the lighting and colors and the main complex structure of the scene with its intricate refelctions and transparencies.

    Entry #: 
    Title: Unstructuring an Epoch
    Artist: evilproducer
    Great lighting and a strong composition - I like the diagonals and the repetition of the those giant mountain shapes.

    Entry #: 6
    Title: When Structures are becoming unstructured.
    Artist: Varsel
    I like the mood created as we get a peek inside this monolithic structure littered by pieces of crumbling debris. I also like the lightbeam illuminating the tree - a sense of renewal and hope.

  • DiomedeDiomede Posts: 15,182

    Votes

    Entry #: 4
    Title: Flesh and Bones
    Artist: headwax-carrara

    Entry #: 6
    Title: When Structures are becoming unstructured.
    Artist: Varsel

    Entry #8
    Title: Ouch!
    Artist: Stezza

    Entry #11
    Title: 47
    Artist: Misty

  • Bunyip02Bunyip02 Posts: 8,691

    Entry #: 4
    Title: Flesh and Bones
    Artist: headwax-carrara

     

    Entry #21

    Title:  The World of Aiko 3

    Artist:  UnifiedBrain

     

    Entry #22

    Title:  “Ear Holder”

    Artist:  Vyusur

     

    Entry #: 24
    Title: Unstructuring the mummy girl
    Artist: evilproducer

     

    Decisions, decisions, decisions.... Excellent work by all !!!!

  • HoroHoro Posts: 10,698

    Difficult as always.

    Entry#: 2
    Title: Somedays Are Like this
    Artist: headwax-carrara

    Entry#: 9
    Title: Building Dominoes
    Artist: Stezza

    Entry#: 14
    Title: What a Butte Cafe !
    Artist: Bunyip02

    Entry#: 22
    Title: “Ear Holder”
    Artist: Vyusur

  • TangoAlphaTangoAlpha Posts: 4,584

    Very tough choices, I changed my mind multiple times.

    Entry #: 9
    Title: Building Dominoes
    Artist: Stezza
    I love how the ant on the right looks kinda pissed off!

    Entry #: 20
    Title: After the Apocalypse
    Artist: UnifiedBrain
    Very atmospheric. I love the kinda metallised effect on the girl.

    Entry #: 22
    Title: Ear Holder
    Artist: Vyusur
    Ello Ello Ello, what's this ear? I guess I deserve A CLIP ROUND THE EAR for that! (groan!)

    Entry #: 25
    Title: Destructive Morphs
    Artist: Vyusur
    Spiky, Zazzy. Blue. I have days like that . . .

  • JamahoneyJamahoney Posts: 1,791

    You Carrara's are so talented and imaginative. Apologies that I can't include your work in my vote, but hang in there. Jay

    Votes below are in respect of first, second...etc., preferences:

    #24

    #4

    #5

    #6

    #20

     

     

  • MelanieLMelanieL Posts: 7,420
    edited July 2019

    My choices:

    Entry#: 2
    Title: Somedays Are Like this
    Artist: Headwax

    Entry#: 7
    Title: Building Blocks
    Artist: Stezza

    Entry#: 9
    Title: Building Dominoes
    Artist: Stezza

    Entry#: 12
    Title: Unstructuring the mummy girl
    Artist: evilproducer

    (Actually I could have done with several more votes, I had to leave out so many that I really liked frown)

    Edit: To fix an artist name - only five letters but I managed to mis-spell!

    Post edited by MelanieL on
  • Yellow PenYellow Pen Posts: 920

    Wow . hard to vote, all are so wonderful... so good luck to you all.

    My Choices:

    Entry #: 12
    Title: Future City
    Artist: Bunyip02

    Entry #10
    Title: Just a random guy constructing or deconstructing with Lego
    Artist: Stezza

    Entry #20

    Title:  After the Apocalypse

    Artist:  UnifiedBrain

     

    Entry #: 25

    Title: Destructive morphs

    Artist: Vyusur

     

     

  • StezzaStezza Posts: 8,116

    Great challenge entries ... was hard picking them this time around... emus do help yes

    my votes in no particular order other than numerical. 

    Entry #: 4
    Title: Flesh and Bones
    Artist: headwax-carrara

    Entry #11
    Title: 47
    Artist: Misty

    Entry #: 25
    Title: Destructive morphs
    Artist: Vyusur

    Entry #28
    Title: "A Miasma of Burbling Angry Flesh"
    Artist: DesertDude

  • S RayS Ray Posts: 399
    Entry #9
    Title:BuildingDominoes
    Artist: Stezza
     
    Entry #20
    Title:  After  the Apocalypse
    Artist:  UnifiedBrain
     
    Entry #22
    Title:  “Ear Holder”
    Artist:  Vyusur
     
    Entry #: 25
    Title: Destructive morphs
    Artist: Vyusur
  • drachenlordsdrachenlords Posts: 821

    Difficult choice.

    Entry #: 22
    Title: Ear Holder
    Artist: Vyusur

    Entry #: 4
    Title: Flesh and Bones
    Artist: headwax-carrara

    Entry # 10
    Title: Just a random guy constructing or deconstructing with Lego
    Artist: Stezza

    Entry #: 14
    Title: What a Butte Cafe!
    Artist: Bunyip02

  • mermaid010mermaid010 Posts: 5,532

     

    Very difficult

    Entry#: 2
    Title: Somedays Are Like this
    Artist: headwax-carrara

    Entry # 10
    Title: Just a random guy constructing or deconstructing with Lego
    Artist: Stezza

    Entry#: 14
    Title: What a Butte Cafe !
    Artist: Bunyip02

    Entry #: 22
    Title: Ear Holder
    Artist: Vyusur

  • DUDUDUDU Posts: 1,945

    Not easy to vote, as usual!

    Entry #: 1
    Title: Cyclopstritch Parade
    Artist: Diomede (Ted Murphy)

    Entry #10
    Title: Just a random guy constructing or deconstructing with Lego
    Artist: Stezza

    Entry #22
    Title:  “Ear Holder”
    Artist:  Vyusur

    Entry #: 24
    Title: Unstructuring the mummy girl
    Artist: evilproducer

  • MistaraMistara Posts: 38,675

    Entry #:6
    Title:  When Structures are becoming unstructured.
    Artist:  Varsel
     -courtyard decorating 

    Entry #10
    Title: Just a random guy constructing or deconstructing with Lego
    Artist: Stezza
     -Dr Feelgood vibe

    Entry: #23
    Title: World Gone Bad
    Artist: Diomede (Ted Murphy)
     -classic B movie vibe

    Entry #: 24
    Title: Unstructuring the mummy girl
    Artist: evilproducer
     - tail swatters  Lol

  • mtnmenmtnmen Posts: 444

    #22

    Ear Holder

    Vyusur

     

    #2

    Some Days Are Like That

    headwax-carrara

     

    #4

    Flesh and Bones

    headwax-carrara

     

    #12

    Future City

    Bunyip02

    Great stuff here again and so different from Bryce... I'm surprised with each challenge

  • ed3Ded3D Posts: 2,215

    Entry #: 14
    Title: What a Butte Cafe !
    Artist: Bunyip02

    Entry #: 24
    Title: Unstructuring the mummy girl
    Artist: evilproducer

    Entry #7
    Title: Building Blocks
    Artist: Stezza

    Entry #21

    Title:  The World of Aiko 3

    Artist:  UnifiedBrain

  • DesertDudeDesertDude Posts: 1,238

    Thanks to everyone who has voted so far. If you haven't had a chance to vote yet you still have one more day to peruse and admire the great artwork here and get your votes in. Thanks!

  • evilproducerevilproducer Posts: 9,050

    I'll try and vote. I've been really busy and haven't had a real chance to decide between all of the excellent entries.

  • HeadwaxHeadwax Posts: 9,996
    edited July 2019

    Entry #: 1
    Title: Cyclopstritch Parade
    Artist: Diomede (Ted Murphy)

    ​------------

    Entry #28
    Title: "A Miasma of Burbling Angry Flesh"
    Artist: DesertDude

    ----------------

    Entry #22

    Title:  “Ear Holder”

    Artist:  Vyusur

    -------------------

    Entry #: 15
    Title: Troll Bridge
    Artist: Bunyip02

    OI must say there were some standout works in this challenge - loved the surrealist ones and stezza's sense of humour

    thanks for sponsoring Vyusur too!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    sorry very quick visit
     

    Post edited by Headwax on
  • UnifiedBrainUnifiedBrain Posts: 3,588

    Sorry for the delay.  Internet was out for several days.

    Entry #5

    Title:  Unstructuring an Epoch

    Artist:  evilproducer

    Comment:  Great ligjhting, poses, and meteors.  Too many trees on the right (for me), but everything else was perfect.

     

    Entry #7

    Title:  Building Blocks

    Artist:  Stezza

    Comment:  His usual interesting perspective, characters, and poses.  Killer concrete shader!

     

    Entry #14

    Title:  What a Butte Cafe !

    Artist:  Bunyip02

    Comment:  Very elegant and pretty

     

    Entry #22

    Title:  Ear Holder

    Artist:  Vyusur

    Comment:  Awesome creativity and use of shaders.  A great example of Octane's power as well.

     

    At least four others were seriously in the running.  Wildly varied entries, which made judging harder than ever.  Congrats to DesertDude for inspiring such a menagerie!

  • 3drendero3drendero Posts: 2,026

    Entry #24

    Title:  Unstructuring the mummy girl

    Artist:  evilproducer

    Comment:  Hilarious. Good enough to sell.

     

    Entry #18

    Title:  The Sorceress

    Artist:  evilproducer

    Comment:  On theme, with special effects, imaginative 

     

    Entry #21

    Title:  The World of Aiko 3

    Artist:  UB

    Comment:  Love the city background and the easter eggs (Carrara, UB2019)

     

    Entry #25

    Title:  Destructive morphs

    Artist:  Vyusur

    Comment: Unique concept, open for interpretation

  • DesertDudeDesertDude Posts: 1,238

    The Voting thread is now closed.

    Thank you all Carrara community for participating in this friendly community challenge, voting, participating and being overall Super Awesome.

    I feel so privelaged to be part of this community.

    Earlier today I started tabulating votes and realized there are...many Ties that can't be realized with coin tosses as per the rules I set out. So,  around noon today I called my neighbor/landlord who is a great friend who lives in the front house here on the property and asked if he would pick numbers out of a hat to solve the multiple ties...he has no idea what Carrara is and only has a vague idea about 3D assets...agh,,,you get the point...

    Believe me it kills me this part but I don't know what else to do. There are multiple ties for 2nd, 3rd, and 4th place. It's past midnight here in the US but I'll see him early in the morning around 7-8-ish.

    Winners will be announced in the morning.

    Thanks again everyone - great artwork!!

     

  • UnifiedBrainUnifiedBrain Posts: 3,588
    edited July 2019

    Ties are always an issue.  With more votes, there are usually less ties.  When I was hosting, I would sometimes need to PM forum members to get them to vote.  The general goal was to have about as many voters as there were entries.

    Another idea, as the host, is to not vote unless there is a need to break ties.

    Whatever.  In my view, there is no perfect solution, or even a clear winner in the popularity contest part of the Challenge .  It's very subjective, but still fun.  We just do the best we can.  :)

    Post edited by UnifiedBrain on
  • 3drendero3drendero Posts: 2,026
    Proposals for improvements for next round -Longer voting periods -Ask the Bryce fans to vote (since they ask Carrara fans sometimes) -PM as UB suggested -Ask in other Carrara forums?
  • DesertDudeDesertDude Posts: 1,238

    Hi all, here are the results:

    1st - #22 Vyusur "Ear Holder"

    2nd - #4 Headwax "Flesh and Bones"

    3rd - #6 Varsel "Structures are becoming unstructured"

    4th - #9 Stezza "Building Dominoes"

    Vyusur chose Stezza's Entry #10 "Random Guy Constructing With Lego" for the PA sponsor prize.

    There was a 5 way tie for 2nd place and a 3 way tie for 3rd and 4th place.  My neighbor picked the entry numbers from a cup to break the ties. 

    Congratulations to the winners. I will PM you with required details.

    Thank you all for voting and participating - awesome work!

    And thanks to DAZ3D and Vyusur for being sponsors!

     

     

     

  • evilproducerevilproducer Posts: 9,050

    Great job everyone!

  • Bunyip02Bunyip02 Posts: 8,691

    Congrats to the winners, huge well done to all who participated, picking just 4 was very hard !!!

    Thanks to DAZ3D & Vyusur for being sponsors.

    Also a big well done to DesertDude for being a great host !

  • Bunyip02Bunyip02 Posts: 8,691
    3drendero said:
    Proposals for improvements for next round -Longer voting periods -Ask the Bryce fans to vote (since they ask Carrara fans sometimes) -PM as UB suggested -Ask in other Carrara forums?

    I asked in the Bryce forum for voters, which they helped out superbly !!!

Sign In or Register to comment.