Getting on the 9 train, or not

1525355575863

Comments

  • alienareaalienarea Posts: 526

    Torquinox said:

    alienarea said:

    8 G9 characters side by side. Careful: they are as delivered, i.e. nude.

    Check the comments.
    https://www.deviantart.com/alien-area/art/The-Bad-Batch-1036047837

    Thanks for that. They look fine, well within normal parameters for healthy human females. If anything, they're all way too perfect for the pursuit of realism. I haven't really thought about specifically adjusting limb length. Height, yes. Real-world, there is a lot of variation. There are long-torso w/short legs, long legs w/short torso, etc. Some folks have long arms, some shorter. Nipples are soft tissue on soft tissue. They are frequently lower than one might think snd position varies, size varies, prominence varies - like breasts themselves. Some people, their nipples point straight down and some people have noticaeble variation between left and right breast. Real humans don't often match up to the ideals for human form. Nothing wrong with what I see except it's all a bit too uniform to be real. 

    You can find an example for everything, sure. But, as a rule of thumb, elbows are around the height of the waistline. Except for Van Helsing, they are not. For the other characters it looks like the legs were shortened and the arms forgotten.

    That leads to this, again nsfw pin-up

    Victoria 9 - Cyberpunk Bedroom by alien-area on DeviantArt
    https://www.deviantart.com/alien-area/art/Victoria-9-Cyberpunk-Bedroom-1035260702

     

     

  • Singular3DSingular3D Posts: 529
    edited March 31

    Wonderland said:

    I'm finding I'm spending way too much time trying to morph G9 to look more like G3 and it's dawning on me, why don't I just use G3? I like the body proportions and faces so much better. Even the bends are better IMO. I like G8 too but I have so much content, she takes like 45 minutes to load. I was thinking of converting some G3 or G8 characters to G9, but why? The make-up system is awful and I can't tweak iris colors or lip gloss easily. After all this time, I still find no advantage to G9. At least these sales are great for scooping up older content at great prices.

    Agree totally. I must admit I rarely bother differentiating between G3 & G8. Most clothing and hair is swappable (shoes less so, but that's the only biggish problem), poses can be cross applied and corrected with ease.  Virtually all textures and skins can be used on both. The only exclusively G3 texture thingy I've come across is Wet & Tanned Skins for G3, and I have an idea how to spoof G8 as G3 for long enough to get it to work - have yet to try it, but the idea is there. The product was definitely the right price, and if all else fails, getting the material right on G3 & saving a temporary material setting isn't a great hardship.

    Regards,

    Richard

    I'm lucky to have Texture Converter 2 that makes it easy to convert V4 textures to G3 UVs. Unfortunately it is no longer available. So, I can even use V4 textures easily with G3 and even mix them with native G3 textures. Helps a lot.
    Post edited by Singular3D on
  • Silent WinterSilent Winter Posts: 3,721

    kyoto kid said:

    Torquinox said:

    I'm increasingly moving to G8 with a fair amount of G3 and still some G2. I have no mechanism for moving hd morphs across generations. That's a limitation and some of .the earlier work is still great! I'll probably do something with G9 some day. It's just, today is not that day.

    ...this will let you move G3 morphs to G8, and it's even on sale right now. 

    https://www.daz3d.com/xtransfer--genesis-3-to-genesis-8-converter

    it even works with morph kits. and Genisis X Utilities 

    Also check Genesis X which as well as the add-ons will  let you transfer morphs from Gen4 and G1/G2 to G3  Morphs and shapes transferred to G3 are also transferable to G8 with the above.   

    https://www.daz3d.com/genesis-generation-x2

    https://www.daz3d.com/genx2-addon-for-genesis-2

    https://www.daz3d.com/genx2-addon-for-genesis-3 (this will lt you  transfer Genesis 2 morphs and shapes to Genesis 3.

    All are also on sale.

    Yes - except it won't transfer HD morphs - so depending on the character, results may vary. 

  • theflarftheflarf Posts: 147

    One thing I've had when I gave G9 a go, is the eyes, on a couple of characters I created I cannot get them to look in the same direction, they just end up with a lazy eye look. 

    Never something I had an issue with on G8 or when I use G3 with background characters.

    I will say for standalone close ups, G9 clearly is a step up, however for the type of scenes I like to do with multiple characters in shot G9 is too hungry and not worth it compared to how easy G8-G3 are to put in several characters 

  • caravellecaravelle Posts: 2,456

    Serene Night said:

    Still find genesis 9 male sub par for me. Not a lot of content, and most content heavily geared towards female presenting figures. Male presenting chests and torso lack interest areas, hair designed with female hairlines, male nipples kind of frustrating experience, coat  hanger shoulders and blocky torsos and pieroscoping necks. 

    You are right. And the unnaturally drooping shoulders with the periscope necks that Daz has always done have actually got worse with the G9 generation.

  • terranullisterranullis Posts: 56

    I'm still finding it hard to justify switching up to g9. Without being able to easily/cleanly apply g8 clothing/hair assets to g9 is the biggest issue I have. I've bought too much g8 clothing/hair. And while more g9 is coming out, a vast majority of it seems (to me) just to be very similar to something I already have for g8 that it'd be like buying it again. I feel a bit... ripped off.

    I'm also with most people saying g9 looks... odd. It just looks stumpier to me. I tried a few g9 characters and messing with sliders, but I can't make any character, especially female, as attractive as easily as with g8. I always feel like I'm fighting g9 to look "sexy". I do a lot of pinup style for book covers and things, so it's important the characters look super-heroic etc. G9 seems more built to make frumpy soccer moms. That doesn't sell. But that's just my worthless internet opinion.

    At this point, I'm grateful to all those creators still making g8/8.1 options with their clothing/hair products. Those I'll always buy. About the only thing G9 has done has increased my bank account. I buy a LOT less than I used to. Not because I don't want more products, as I always want more, but I'm having to go to other sites which still focus on g8/8.1. They're not as good, and I'm having to learn the art of texturing, but it works for what I do.

    On the plus side, I've downloaded Blender and Zbrush and have been starting the rabbithole of tutorials to try and make my own things now I'm facing not having as many products to buy. One door closes and one opens, I suppose.

     

     

  • TorquinoxTorquinox Posts: 3,322

    kyoto kid said:

    Torquinox said:

    I'm increasingly moving to G8 with a fair amount of G3 and still some G2. I have no mechanism for moving hd morphs across generations. That's a limitation and some of .the earlier work is still great! I'll probably do something with G9 some day. It's just, today is not that day.

    ...this will let you move G3 morphs to G8, and it's even on sale right now. 

    https://www.daz3d.com/xtransfer--genesis-3-to-genesis-8-converter

    it even works with morph kits. and Genisis X Utilities 

    Also check Genesis X which as well as the add-ons will  let you transfer morphs from Gen4 and G1/G2 to G3  Morphs and shapes transferred to G3 are also transferable to G8 with the above.   

    https://www.daz3d.com/genesis-generation-x2

    https://www.daz3d.com/genx2-addon-for-genesis-2

    https://www.daz3d.com/genx2-addon-for-genesis-3 (this will lt you  transfer Genesis 2 morphs and shapes to Genesis 3.

    All are also on sale.

    Thanks my friend. I already bought and have been using all of them! Very cool! I'm even moving my favorite V4s up the ladder. laugh

  • TorquinoxTorquinox Posts: 3,322

    Silent Winter said:

    kyoto kid said:

    ...this will let you move G3 morphs to G8, and it's even on sale right now. 

    https://www.daz3d.com/xtransfer--genesis-3-to-genesis-8-converter

    it even works with morph kits. and Genisis X Utilities 

    Also check Genesis X which as well as the add-ons will  let you transfer morphs from Gen4 and G1/G2 to G3  Morphs and shapes transferred to G3 are also transferable to G8 with the above.   

    https://www.daz3d.com/genesis-generation-x2

    https://www.daz3d.com/genx2-addon-for-genesis-2

    https://www.daz3d.com/genx2-addon-for-genesis-3 (this will lt you  transfer Genesis 2 morphs and shapes to Genesis 3.

    All are also on sale.

    Yes - except it won't transfer HD morphs - so depending on the character, results may vary. 

    I noticed. Nothing to do for it. Still, it's increasing my possibilities, and I'm pleased with the results.

  • TorquinoxTorquinox Posts: 3,322

    Singular3D said:

    I'm lucky to have Texture Converter 2 that makes it easy to convert V4 textures to G3 UVs. Unfortunately it is no longer available. So, I can even use V4 textures easily with G3 and even mix them with native G3 textures. Helps a lot.

    I wondered about that. Lucky you! Without it, the best I could do is https://www.daz3d.com/legacy-uvs-for-genesis-8-victoria-4 . Otherwise, I could get get textures to G2 using https://www.daz3d.com/v4-skins-batch-converter-to-genesis-2-female-s or https://www.daz3d.com/v4-skins-auto-converter-for-genesis-2-female-s . Both require https://www.daz3d.com/victoria-4-for-genesis-2-female . Then I guess I'd add https://www.daz3d.com/legacy-uvs-for-genesis-8-genesis-2-female unless there is another way to convert G2 skins to G3 or G8 - Cludgy by comparison.

  • TorquinoxTorquinox Posts: 3,322

    alienarea said:

    You can find an example for everything, sure. But, as a rule of thumb, elbows are around the height of the waistline. Except for Van Helsing, they are not. For the other characters it looks like the legs were shortened and the arms forgotten.

    That leads to this, again nsfw pin-up

    Victoria 9 - Cyberpunk Bedroom by alien-area on DeviantArt
    https://www.deviantart.com/alien-area/art/Victoria-9-Cyberpunk-Bedroom-1035260702

    Indeed. Have I ever mentioned how much I don't like V9? Seems she has some reach, though. You wouldn't want to box with her.

  • NylonGirlNylonGirl Posts: 1,811

    Torquinox said:

    alienarea said:

    You can find an example for everything, sure. But, as a rule of thumb, elbows are around the height of the waistline. Except for Van Helsing, they are not. For the other characters it looks like the legs were shortened and the arms forgotten.

    That leads to this, again nsfw pin-up

    Victoria 9 - Cyberpunk Bedroom by alien-area on DeviantArt
    https://www.deviantart.com/alien-area/art/Victoria-9-Cyberpunk-Bedroom-1035260702

    Indeed. Have I ever mentioned how much I don't like V9? Seems she has some reach, though. You wouldn't want to box with her.

    She looks good eating chicken nuggets though. 

  • alienareaalienarea Posts: 526

    Just compare the bending and body details and decide for yourself.

    On the left is Victoria 8.1 HD, on the right Victoria 9 HD.  Both wear basic panties and bra from the respective starter essentials and the Voss hair for their generation.

    The pose is from Z Ultimate Kneeling and Crouching for Genesis 8 and 9 | Daz 3D Full 03 Kneeling Mirror.

    Victoria 8.1 HD vs Victoria 9 HD by alien-area on DeviantArt

    Then I did the same picture with Victoria 8.1 dialed out and Victoria 7 for Victoria 8 dialed in.

    Victoria 7 for Victoria 8 HD vs Victoria 9 HD by alien-area on DeviantArt

  • richardandtracyrichardandtracy Posts: 5,675
    Points of less good body in that latter image: V9 neck front crease at clavicle (not seen on any previous generation), thigh bulge (as bad as V3) and concave shin (as bad as GV3). To be honest, the body shape of V9 is better than V3, but there are features of the rigging that are not hugely in advance of V3, and do seem to be a step backwards from G8. The head, though, seems no worse at that range.
  • kyoto kidkyoto kid Posts: 41,046

    ...well picked up the Essentials Bundle (Body/Head Shapes Expressions and Starter Essentials Expansion) for 7.78$, as I had a couple  tokens to use up and a couple Easter eggs which gave an additional discount on Daz Os.

  • TorquinoxTorquinox Posts: 3,322

    How well does https://www.daz3d.com/natural-movements-pack-for-genesis-9 and/or https://www.daz3d.com/ultimate-natural-bend-morphs-for-genesis-9-female-base fix these posing issues? Neither one is on sale today, though I would think either or both could go a long way to addressing the issues with posing g9

  • MelissaGTMelissaGT Posts: 2,611

    alienarea said:

    Just compare the bending and body details and decide for yourself.

    On the left is Victoria 8.1 HD, on the right Victoria 9 HD.  Both wear basic panties and bra from the respective starter essentials and the Voss hair for their generation.

    The pose is from Z Ultimate Kneeling and Crouching for Genesis 8 and 9 | Daz 3D Full 03 Kneeling Mirror.

    Victoria 8.1 HD vs Victoria 9 HD by alien-area on DeviantArt

    Then I did the same picture with Victoria 8.1 dialed out and Victoria 7 for Victoria 8 dialed in.

    Victoria 7 for Victoria 8 HD vs Victoria 9 HD by alien-area on DeviantArt

    I've noticed that poses made for G8 and converted to G9 look terrible...not sure if the poses in that set were designed separately for each figure.

    I haven't had bad experience with bends once I realized that you need to make sure all the pose enhancement toggles are turned on. Elbows was always my pet peeve with G8/8.1...and with G9, I was pleasantly surprised.  

  • alienareaalienarea Posts: 526

    Torquinox said:

    How well does https://www.daz3d.com/natural-movements-pack-for-genesis-9 and/or https://www.daz3d.com/ultimate-natural-bend-morphs-for-genesis-9-female-base fix these posing issues? Neither one is on sale today, though I would think either or both could go a long way to addressing the issues with posing g9

    I have the ultimate natural bend morphs, will do a comparison picture tomorrow.

  • TorquinoxTorquinox Posts: 3,322
    edited April 1

    alienarea said:

    I have the ultimate natural bend morphs, will do a comparison picture tomorrow.

    Thank you. I'll be interested to see :) edit: typo

    Post edited by Torquinox on
  • MelissaGTMelissaGT Posts: 2,611

    Torquinox said:

    How well does https://www.daz3d.com/natural-movements-pack-for-genesis-9 and/or https://www.daz3d.com/ultimate-natural-bend-morphs-for-genesis-9-female-base fix these posing issues? Neither one is on sale today, though I would think either or both could go a long way to addressing the issues with posing g9

    I have both and I get way more mileage out of the first one. I would recommend both, but if you can only get one, go with that one. The Ultimate Natural Bend Morphs I've found ends up over-correcting in many cases and you can't just apply the "all" slider and go...you have to be very specific with what corrections you want turned on. Often I find myself using a combination of the two. But the realism Natural Movements Pack brings to hands is a must-have.  

  • TorquinoxTorquinox Posts: 3,322

    MelissaGT said:

    I've noticed that poses made for G8 and converted to G9 look terrible...not sure if the poses in that set were designed separately for each figure.

    I haven't had bad experience with bends once I realized that you need to make sure all the pose enhancement toggles are turned on. Elbows was always my pet peeve with G8/8.1...and with G9, I was pleasantly surprised.  

    So, turning on these enhancements help resolve some of the odd bending issues? That would be good.

  • TorquinoxTorquinox Posts: 3,322

    MelissaGT said:

    Torquinox said:

    How well does https://www.daz3d.com/natural-movements-pack-for-genesis-9 and/or https://www.daz3d.com/ultimate-natural-bend-morphs-for-genesis-9-female-base fix these posing issues? Neither one is on sale today, though I would think either or both could go a long way to addressing the issues with posing g9

    I have both and I get way more mileage out of the first one. I would recommend both, but if you can only get one, go with that one. The Ultimate Natural Bend Morphs I've found ends up over-correcting in many cases and you can't just apply the "all" slider and go...you have to be very specific with what corrections you want turned on. Often I find myself using a combination of the two. But the realism Natural Movements Pack brings to hands is a must-have.  

    Thank you! I That is good to know.

  • MelissaGTMelissaGT Posts: 2,611

    Torquinox said:

    MelissaGT said:

    I've noticed that poses made for G8 and converted to G9 look terrible...not sure if the poses in that set were designed separately for each figure.

    I haven't had bad experience with bends once I realized that you need to make sure all the pose enhancement toggles are turned on. Elbows was always my pet peeve with G8/8.1...and with G9, I was pleasantly surprised.  

    So, turning on these enhancements help resolve some of the odd bending issues? That would be good.

    Yes, G9 has base toggles that you need to make sure are turned on. That fixes a lot of the issues. They are not turned on by default and I think that is the source of most of the problems people are having -  

    flexion sliders.png
    877 x 473 - 68K
  • MelissaGTMelissaGT Posts: 2,611

    Torquinox said:

    MelissaGT said:

    Torquinox said:

    How well does https://www.daz3d.com/natural-movements-pack-for-genesis-9 and/or https://www.daz3d.com/ultimate-natural-bend-morphs-for-genesis-9-female-base fix these posing issues? Neither one is on sale today, though I would think either or both could go a long way to addressing the issues with posing g9

    I have both and I get way more mileage out of the first one. I would recommend both, but if you can only get one, go with that one. The Ultimate Natural Bend Morphs I've found ends up over-correcting in many cases and you can't just apply the "all" slider and go...you have to be very specific with what corrections you want turned on. Often I find myself using a combination of the two. But the realism Natural Movements Pack brings to hands is a must-have.  

    Thank you! I That is good to know.

    Actually, it's the Natural Movements Pack that can over-correct. That's the one you have to apply individually for best results. But I still stand by the realism that it gives to hands.  

    The reality is...I would definitely try to get both when they go on sale. 

  • TorquinoxTorquinox Posts: 3,322

    MelissaGT said:

    Actually, it's the Natural Movements Pack that can over-correct. That's the one you have to apply individually for best results. But I still stand by the realism that it gives to hands.  

    The reality is...I would definitely try to get both when they go on sale. 

    Makes sense! That's my plan :) 

  • TorquinoxTorquinox Posts: 3,322

    MelissaGT said:

    Torquinox said:

    MelissaGT said:

    I've noticed that poses made for G8 and converted to G9 look terrible...not sure if the poses in that set were designed separately for each figure.

    I haven't had bad experience with bends once I realized that you need to make sure all the pose enhancement toggles are turned on. Elbows was always my pet peeve with G8/8.1...and with G9, I was pleasantly surprised.  

    So, turning on these enhancements help resolve some of the odd bending issues? That would be good.

    Yes, G9 has base toggles that you need to make sure are turned on. That fixes a lot of the issues. They are not turned on by default and I think that is the source of most of the problems people are having -  

    I will make sure to do that. Thanks again!

  • kyoto kidkyoto kid Posts: 41,046

    MelissaGT said:

    alienarea said:

    Just compare the bending and body details and decide for yourself.

    On the left is Victoria 8.1 HD, on the right Victoria 9 HD.  Both wear basic panties and bra from the respective starter essentials and the Voss hair for their generation.

    The pose is from Z Ultimate Kneeling and Crouching for Genesis 8 and 9 | Daz 3D Full 03 Kneeling Mirror.

    Victoria 8.1 HD vs Victoria 9 HD by alien-area on DeviantArt

    Then I did the same picture with Victoria 8.1 dialed out and Victoria 7 for Victoria 8 dialed in.

    Victoria 7 for Victoria 8 HD vs Victoria 9 HD by alien-area on DeviantArt

    I've noticed that poses made for G8 and converted to G9 look terrible...not sure if the poses in that set were designed separately for each figure.

    I haven't had bad experience with bends once I realized that you need to make sure all the pose enhancement toggles are turned on. Elbows was always my pet peeve with G8/8.1...and with G9, I was pleasantly surprised.  

     ...so what about Riversoft Art's Bone Minion for Genesis 9 or Zev0's Pose Converter for G3/8/8.1 to G9? 

  • TimbalesTimbales Posts: 2,333
    I was working on something this weekend and found G8/8.1M body shapes make G9 much more pleasant to use. Unfortunately you can't mix them with G9M characters bodies.
  • WonderlandWonderland Posts: 6,876

    I was thinking of converting V7 and V8 to G9 to get a better starting figure. Has anyone tried that? I'm still going back to using G8 and G3 (have a bunch of super discounted items in my cart right now,) but thinking it would at least make G9 easier to use instead of having to make the legs longer and body more to my liking each time and struggling with lipstick/lipgloss issues. But then all G9 poses will be wonky. Kind of wish I never invested in G9 at all. With my huge cart today of super cheap G8 & G3 items, I will soon own most of the store for those products lol. And I now have enough characters and utilities for G9 that I can't imagine needing more. But I wish PAs would make all new hair and clothing have G8 versions. Based on the forums, it seems like a lot of people still prefer the older characters. 

  • MelissaGTMelissaGT Posts: 2,611
    edited April 2

    kyoto kid said:

    MelissaGT said:

    alienarea said:

    Just compare the bending and body details and decide for yourself.

    On the left is Victoria 8.1 HD, on the right Victoria 9 HD.  Both wear basic panties and bra from the respective starter essentials and the Voss hair for their generation.

    The pose is from Z Ultimate Kneeling and Crouching for Genesis 8 and 9 | Daz 3D Full 03 Kneeling Mirror.

    Victoria 8.1 HD vs Victoria 9 HD by alien-area on DeviantArt

    Then I did the same picture with Victoria 8.1 dialed out and Victoria 7 for Victoria 8 dialed in.

    Victoria 7 for Victoria 8 HD vs Victoria 9 HD by alien-area on DeviantArt

    I've noticed that poses made for G8 and converted to G9 look terrible...not sure if the poses in that set were designed separately for each figure.

    I haven't had bad experience with bends once I realized that you need to make sure all the pose enhancement toggles are turned on. Elbows was always my pet peeve with G8/8.1...and with G9, I was pleasantly surprised.  

     ...so what about Riversoft Art's Bone Minion for Genesis 9 or Zev0's Pose Converter for G3/8/8.1 to G9? 

    The only one of those I have is the later...and it's been my experience that poses coverted from G8/8.1 to G9 look weird in the shoulder/neck area. I haven't tried from G3, but I would expect the same result, given how similar G3 is to G8. My only guess is that the different bone structure in the shoulders/neck is the culprit. 

    In my example, I put G8M (left) next to the base G9 (right). It's an extreme pose example, but it does illustrate the shoulders/neck issue very well. 

    wonky spine.png
    1715 x 923 - 353K
    wonky spine 2.png
    1725 x 963 - 368K
    Post edited by MelissaGT on
  • MendomanMendoman Posts: 404

    I'm still riding on the 8-train, but I have to admit, there have been a couple of very good-looking hair products I wish were available for G8 characters also. Mos of the characters and clothes still give me the fibe that I already own it, so not in a rush to change trains. At this point, I think I'll wait for the Daz5 to release to see if anything mind-blowing is coming for G9, and if not, then I think I'll just wait and see what G10 will look like,

Sign In or Register to comment.