New Genesis, New Sales Thread: Report Issues Here "Reporting Only"

11415171920100

Comments

  • zombietaggerungzombietaggerung Posts: 3,726
    edited December 2022

    This is what it says on mine. i only once got up to 3 punches then immediately went back down to one. There is zero explanation as to why/how in the description.

    Screenshot 2022-12-09 172021.jpg
    1081 x 814 - 135K
    Post edited by zombietaggerung on
  • barbultbarbult Posts: 24,249
    edited December 2022

    The only difference I have seen between different people's offers is the max loyalty discount number. The offer seems to work the same way for everyone who has posted. It goes from 3 punches to 1 punch as soon as you miss a day of purchasing. Where does the ad describe that???? It says "Purchase daily to stack your Holiday Loyalty Discount". Nowhere does it say that you will lose punches once you earn them. Real punch cards get a hole in them for every punch. Those holes do not magically close back up after being punched. How can Daz not see that this sale makes no sense to customers?

    Customers are asking for an explanation of how the punch card is supposed to work, but we can't get any explanation from Daz. We are just told to read the words, but we've been reading those same words for days, and they don't suddenly make any more sense today.

    This is what mine says:

    Punch Card.jpg
    772 x 689 - 119K
    Post edited by barbult on
  • DanaTADanaTA Posts: 13,214

    Richard Haseltine said:

    Sorry, there are actually different offers - please read the details above/below the punch card artwork as there is not one set of rules for all.

    That sounds like a reason for a mutiny!  Different  rules for some of us?  Starting to sound an awful lot like real life, now!

    Dana

  • barbultbarbult Posts: 24,249

    DanaTA said:

    Richard Haseltine said:

    Sorry, there are actually different offers - please read the details above/below the punch card artwork as there is not one set of rules for all.

    That sounds like a reason for a mutiny!  Different  rules for some of us?  Starting to sound an awful lot like real life, now!

    Dana

    I suspect, with no evidence, that the max discount depends on how much money you spent during some specific period of time. 

  • kyoto kidkyoto kid Posts: 41,062
    edited December 2022

    ...OK new flash sale however clicking the link takes me to a blank store page with no items.

    flash sale page.png
    1670 x 526 - 59K
    Post edited by kyoto kid on
  • Charlie JudgeCharlie Judge Posts: 12,745
    edited December 2022

    kyoto kid said:

    ...OK new flash sale however clicking the link takes me to a blank store page with no items.

     

    I get this page: https://www.daz3d.com/winter-fun-artists-deals

    ETA: Uncheck the 'Only show +'block

    Post edited by Charlie Judge on
  • kyoto kidkyoto kid Posts: 41,062
    edited December 2022

    ...wonder why I don't. I tried it again and nothing.  Where I am I only have less than 3 hours as Daz is in the next time zone one hour ahead. 

    I'm signed in so that shouldn't be the issue. Really annoyed as we can used our holiday sale punches on this and Stonemason is one of the PAs.

    Post edited by kyoto kid on
  • Charlie JudgeCharlie Judge Posts: 12,745
    edited December 2022

    kyoto kid said:

    ...wonder why I don't. I tried it again and nothing.  Where I am I only have less than 3 hours as Daz is in the next time zone one hour ahead. 

    I'm signed in so that shouldn't be the issue. Really annoyed as we can used our holiday sale punches on this and Stonemason is one of the PAs.

    Because you have the 'Only Show +' block checked. 

    Post edited by Charlie Judge on
  • barbult said:

    The only difference I have seen between different people's offers is the max loyalty discount number. The offer seems to work the same way for everyone who has posted. It goes from 3 punches to 1 punch as soon as you miss a day of purchasing. Where does the ad describe that???? It says "Purchase daily to stack your Holiday Loyalty Discount". Nowhere does it say that you will lose punches once you earn them. Real punch cards get a hole in them for every punch. Those holes do not magically close back up after being punched. How can Daz not see that this sale makes no sense to customers?

    Customers are asking for an explanation of how the punch card is supposed to work, but we can't get any explanation from Daz. We are just told to read the words, but we've been reading those same words for days, and they don't suddenly make any more sense today.

    This is what mine says:

    This is the offer I have, too. And I still don't understand it, having read it yet again. 

  • WonderlandWonderland Posts: 6,891
    edited December 2022

    Mine says this but it never goes to 20%. It goes back and forth from 10% to 35%. When I don't buy something for one day, it goes straight to 10%, never to 20%. 

    790FFAE6-C439-49B8-82AC-05D97E2E214B.jpeg
    2003 x 1469 - 1M
    Post edited by Wonderland on
  • Cris PalominoCris Palomino Posts: 11,396
    edited December 2022

    Wonderland said:

    Mine says this but it never goes to 20%. It goes back and forth from 10% to 35%. When I don't buy something for one day, it goes straight to 10%, never to 20%. 

    That is because since Daz is giving you 10% off the bat in this tier, when you purchase, it goes to 35%. 

    Post edited by Cris Palomino on
  • zombietaggerungzombietaggerung Posts: 3,726
    edited December 2022

    Cris Palomino said:

    Wonderland said:

    Mine says this but it never goes to 20%. It goes back and forth from 10% to 35%. When I don't buy something for one day, it goes straight to 10%, never to 20%. 

    That is because since Daz is giving you 10% off the bat in this tier, when you purchase, it goes to 35%. 

    I still really don't understand how that works. They give a 10% off, we buy once over $2 and get two punches? Then don't buy one day and lose both punches? But shouldn't it be either having to buy two days in a row both over $2, get 2 punches. Then don't buy one day lose one punch? Or don't buy two days then lose two punches? This is very confusing. Or maybe I'm just stupid. indecision

    Post edited by zombietaggerung on
  • zombietaggerung said:

    Cris Palomino said:

    Wonderland said:

    Mine says this but it never goes to 20%. It goes back and forth from 10% to 35%. When I don't buy something for one day, it goes straight to 10%, never to 20%. 

    That is because since Daz is giving you 10% off the bat in this tier, when you purchase, it goes to 35%. 

    I still really don't understand how that works. They give a 10% off, we buy once over $2 and get two punches? Then don't buy one day and lose both punches? But shouldn't it be either having to buy two days in a row both over $2, get 2 punches. Then don't buy one day lose one punch? Or don't buy two days then lose two punches? This is very confusing. Or maybe I'm just stupid. indecision

    No, because you didn't purchase two to get 35%. I think of it as an incentive. 

  • barbultbarbult Posts: 24,249
    edited December 2022

    I don't think we are stupid. I think nobody has ever explained clearly how it is supposed to work and what the logic is behind that. Nobody has even answered the very specific questions we have asked.

    Post edited by barbult on
  • Cris Palomino said:

    Wonderland said:

    Mine says this but it never goes to 20%. It goes back and forth from 10% to 35%. When I don't buy something for one day, it goes straight to 10%, never to 20%. 

    That is because since Daz is giving you 10% off the bat in this tier, when you purchase, it goes to 35%. 

    So... it's purely about whether or not you purchased something the day before, and the 20% punch is just on the card for fun?

    Otherwise I don't understand what you are saying.

  • Cris PalominoCris Palomino Posts: 11,396
    edited December 2022

    AlmightyQUEST said:

    Cris Palomino said:

    Wonderland said:

    Mine says this but it never goes to 20%. It goes back and forth from 10% to 35%. When I don't buy something for one day, it goes straight to 10%, never to 20%. 

    That is because since Daz is giving you 10% off the bat in this tier, when you purchase, it goes to 35%. 

    So... it's purely about whether or not you purchased something the day before, and the 20% punch is just on the card for fun?

    Otherwise I don't understand what you are saying.

    If Daz didn't do the first 10%, you'd have to buy twice to get the 35%. You would have had this message explaining they filled in the first punch as a thank you.

     

    Post edited by Cris Palomino on
  • Am I not supposed to be seeing three circles in the picture, am I only supposed to be seeing one that says 10% and one that says 35%? I know other people are asking the same question I am, I'm not sure how this many people can be clearer. What am I missing between three punches in the picture and only two tiers of discounts?
  • maikdeckermaikdecker Posts: 2,752

    barbult said:

    I don't think we are stupid. I think nobody has ever explained clearly how it is supposed to work and what the logic is behind that. Nobody has even answered the very specific questions we have asked.

    The problem here might be, that nobody doing the answering here really does know the answer(s)? Or it works after the - what we germans call it - "Stille Post" (Silent Post... but not a literal translation) principle, where a tells something to B, B to C, C to D and so on, and on each progressing small parts of the communication get unwittingly changed a bit, so as the result the last communication has a total different meaning than the basic first one..

    tldr: wouldn't it be nice if someone from marketing who is responsible for the punches would find the time to explain here in forum who the punches are supposed to work?

  • HylasHylas Posts: 4,989

    For the record, I too am thouroughly confused about how the punch card is supposed to work, although I'm not super invested anymore in figuring it out. I also have a "middle hole" (20%) that is seemingly there for nothing, it keeps jumping between the 1st hole (10%) and the 3rd hole (25%). If nothing else the communication re this sale could be better because the promo text does not explain why it's doing that.

  • barbultbarbult Posts: 24,249
    I'm with you on the "not super invested" part. I haven't found anything interesting enough to spend money on for a few days, so it doesn't matter how many punches I have or what my discount is. If I spend $0, 0 times any discount is still 0. But it bugs me that it makes no sense and nobody can explain it so we understand.
  • WonderlandWonderland Posts: 6,891

    There is literally no way to get 20% off. It's either 10% or 35%, this is what the mods seem not to understand. That middle punch seems to just be decor. 

  • yeah this is weird not that I am spending anything but it was 35% for me yesterday and 10% today, that's a wild swing if you don't buy something everyday

  • Wonderland said:

    There is literally no way to get 20% off. It's either 10% or 35%, this is what the mods seem not to understand. That middle punch seems to just be decor. 

    I think you might be right. Whatever. Something on my wishlist is on sale today for a price I'm willing to pay, so i'll just buy that and not worry about punches. 10, 20, 30, who cares. It still doesn't make a lick of sense to me though. indecision

  • RangerRickRangerRick Posts: 272
    edited December 2022

    barbult said:

    I'm with you on the "not super invested" part. I haven't found anything interesting enough to spend money on for a few days, so it doesn't matter how many punches I have or what my discount is. If I spend $0, 0 times any discount is still 0. But it bugs me that it makes no sense and nobody can explain it so we understand.

    At the risk of making things worse, I suspect they're reseting the punch count to zero if you skip a day and counting the gratis first punch twice but only if you made a purchase the day before. It's difficult to tell because, if I remember correctly, there was a problem getting the punch card display to update correctly in the beginning of this promotion.

    So, let's say you bought stuff Monday through Wednesday and have the 3rd punch at the start of Thursday giving the maximum discount, whatever that is. Thursday there's nothing you want to buy so at the rollover to Friday the punch count is zero'd and then the gratis first punch (10%) is granted.  If you buy something on Friday then you'll get another punch during the rollover to Saturday. Normal math would get you that 20% off middle punch. But not DAZ math. I suspect that during the rollover from Friday to Saturday, If you bought something on Friday then you have two bunches and it add the gratis first punch (again) and *bingo* 3 punches and max discount on Saturday.

    Is that what people are seeing?

    (note that I have no idea what's really going on. But after 35-years in "IT", while many things aggravate me, few things surprise me.)

    (edited to fix a type and add a word)

    Post edited by RangerRick on
  • AnEye4ArtAnEye4Art Posts: 766
    edited December 2022

    WendyLuvsCatz said:

    yeah this is weird not that I am spending anything but it was 35% for me yesterday and 10% today, that's a wild swing if you don't buy something everyday

    So true. I was so invested until there wasn't anything good worth buying. Then I went from 35%, skipped 20%, to 10% just because I did not buy anything - for one day. It feels good to buy and it feels good to keep my money too. 

    Post edited by AnEye4Art on
  • tsroemitsroemi Posts: 2,755

    RangerRick said:

    barbult said:

    I'm with you on the "not super invested" part. I haven't found anything interesting enough to spend money on for a few days, so it doesn't matter how many punches I have or what my discount is. If I spend $0, 0 times any discount is still 0. But it bugs me that it makes no sense and nobody can explain it so we understand.

    At the risk of making things worse, I suspect they're reseting the punch count to zero if you skip a day and counting the gratis first punch twice but only if you made a purchase the day before. It's difficult to tell because, if I remember correctly, there was a problem getting the punch card display to update correctly in the beginning of this promotion.

    So, let's say you bought stuff Monday through Wednesday and have the 3rd punch at the start of Thursday giving the maximum discount, whatever that is. Thursday there's nothing you want to buy so at the rollover to Friday the punch count is zero'd and then the gratis first punch (10%) is granted.  If you buy something on Friday then you'll get another punch during the rollover to Saturday. Normal math would get you that 20% off middle punch. But not DAZ math. I suspect that during the rollover from Friday to Saturday, If you bought something on Friday then you have two bunches and it add the gratis first punch (again) and *bingo* 3 punches and max discount on Saturday.

    Is that what people are seeing?

    (note that I have no idea what's really going on. But after 35-years in "IT", while many things aggravate me, few things surprise me.)

    (edited to fix a type and add a word)

    I think you're right, and the whole system is completely bonkers. I stopped trying to keep up with the punches; I never much tried to begin with, but since the Black Friday sale worked out so nicely, I figured, why not give it a try again. But the punch card thingie makes no sense at all to me and is just plain annoying. I'm also kind of mad really, because we used to get our loyalty percantage off for the whole of the holiday sale, without having to buy stuff again and again just to keep it up. My % off used to be at least 25% usually. So now I actually only get 10% off if I don't buy like a mad thing every single day. Sorry, but the offers are just not there for me.

    The one thing that makes this holiday sale a good thing for me are the truly lovely freebies that the PAs (not DAZ, mind you) are creating for us. The rest is - mostly annoyance, really.

  • AriphaosAriphaos Posts: 66
    edited December 2022

    Irrelevant - deleted.

    Post edited by Ariphaos on
  • Cris Palomino said:

    Wonderland said:

    Mine says this but it never goes to 20%. It goes back and forth from 10% to 35%. When I don't buy something for one day, it goes straight to 10%, never to 20%. 

    That is because since Daz is giving you 10% off the bat in this tier, when you purchase, it goes to 35%. 

    So what is the purpose of the "20% off" if not a single customer of ever sees it?

    To be fair, it is probably better this way, but it adds to the confusion and is annoying.

  • Ariphaos said:

    vagans said:

    I really don't get this extra loyalty bonus. I've tried any items at all from the anniversary sale page and it doesn't apply to anything at all. Does that loyalty bonus require a previous day purchase?

    For me, I get the full 35% if I've made a purchase the previous day, or 10% if I didn't. Nothing ever in between.

    Kind of whatever. 

    This does seem to be how it is working, and Daz did check the rules so I assume it is the intent (and it does say purchase daily, apaprently for everyone). So far I have purchased daily, so I haven't directly seen the missed day behaviour.

  • frank0314frank0314 Posts: 14,066

    barbult said:

    I'm with you on the "not super invested" part. I haven't found anything interesting enough to spend money on for a few days, so it doesn't matter how many punches I have or what my discount is. If I spend $0, 0 times any discount is still 0. But it bugs me that it makes no sense and nobody can explain it so we understand.

    What aren't you understanding? It's been explained may times over how it works, so what's confusing you?

This discussion has been closed.